
The journal
What a storage lien actually is, and what the auction shows leave out
New York Lien Law s 182, in sequence, and the four points at which the whole thing stops — which is where it stops nearly every time.
The lien attaches the day your property arrives
New York Lien Law, article 8, section 182 (opens the statute in a new tab) gives a self-service storage facility a lien on the property in a unit for unpaid charges. Three things about it surprise most people who read it for the first time: it attaches on the day your property is brought here, not on the day you fall behind; it ranks ahead of any other security interest in the goods; and it exists whether or not a facility's website ever mentions it. This one does, in full, rather than in a clause you initial afterwards.
None of what follows is legal advice. It is the sequence the statute sets out, in the order it happens, and — just as importantly — the two places the statute stops talking and this page stops guessing.
Four points where it stops, in order
The full sequence is below. Four moments in it are the ones worth knowing before any of it starts, because each one is a point at which this has never become anything for almost everybody who reaches it.
First, the rent is late — after ten days, with one late fee that does not compound and stops the moment the account is current.
Second, the gate code stops working. Nothing in the unit is touched and nothing is opened; the account simply cannot get back in until it is current. This is where almost everything that starts, ends.
Third, a written notice, and the statute governs this one closely: it has to itemise what is owed, describe the property, and demand payment within a period of not less than thirty days.
Fourth, ten days inside that window to dispute it. The notice has to tell you that you may bring a proceeding within ten days if you dispute the lien itself or the amount claimed — a real remedy, written into the statute, and the step almost nobody knows is there.
The rent is late
Rent is due on the same date each month and is late after ten days. One late fee, not a daily one, and it does not compound.
The code stops working
An account in arrears loses its gate code. The unit is not opened, nothing is touched and nothing is moved — you simply cannot get in until the account is current. This is the step at which most of it ends, and it is meant to be.
Written notice, and thirty days at the least
A notice goes to the address on the agreement — and to the e-mail address on it, if you chose e-mail and gave it in the two places the statute requires. It has to itemise what is owed, describe the property, and demand payment within a period of not less than thirty days. It also has to tell you that you may bring a proceeding within ten days if you dispute the lien or the amount.
Your ten days, and the court
Those ten days are a real remedy and they are in the statute: a special proceeding can cancel the lien or reduce what is claimed. This is the step almost nobody knows about, which is most of the reason it is printed here.
Sale, if it ever gets that far
The goods may then be sold, publicly or privately, in a commercially reasonable manner — and selling more than is needed to clear what is owed is specifically not commercially reasonable. What this site will not tell you is what happens to any money left over, or where a sale must be advertised, because the statute does not say and we are not going to invent an answer. Ask a lawyer.
Your medication and your papers, whatever the account says
At any point in all of the above, including after a notice has gone out, you may ask us to retrieve prescription medication or identity documents from your unit and we will. Refusing is an unconscionable trade practice in this city, and it would be a disgraceful thing to do in any case.
If it ever gets as far as a sale
The property may then be sold, publicly or privately, in a commercially reasonable manner. One specific practice is called out and ruled against by name: selling more of the goods than is actually needed to clear what is owed is not commercially reasonable, whatever else about the sale is.
Your medication and your papers, whatever the account says
At any point in the sequence above, including after a notice has gone out, you may ask to have prescription medication or identity documents retrieved from your unit, and it will be done. Refusing that is an unconscionable trade practice in this city, and it would be a disgraceful thing to do in any case, in arrears or not.
What this page will not tell you, on purpose
Two of these are things a good number of storage websites state as settled fact. They checked out as unsettled or simply untrue when we read the statute itself, so this page says that instead of repeating them.
Three things this page will not tell you
- That the statute requires a newspaper advertisement. It requires the notice to SAY the goods will be advertised for sale, and says nothing about where or how often.
- That any surplus from a sale is automatically returned to you. Section 182 is silent on surplus; a different article of the Lien Law deals with it and whether that article governs a storage sale is unsettled.
- That a facility can sell your things quickly. Thirty days of demand is the statutory minimum before a sale can even be reached, and there is a ten-day window to go to court inside it.
Ask a lawyer, honestly
The statute is silent on what happens to money left over after a sale clears what is owed — a different article of the Lien Law deals with surplus proceeds generally, and whether that article governs a self-storage sale specifically is genuinely unsettled. We would rather tell you that plainly than invent an answer that sounds tidier.
Two things about this building rather than about the law, to close on. We telephone before we write, every time. And nobody who works here is paid anything that depends on a unit being sold — this trade has operators for whom an auction is a line of revenue, and this page exists partly to say that this is not one of them.
The clause itself, in the order the agreement states it, is on the occupancy agreement page, and the shorter version of this same argument is on the boundary page it grew out of.
Hold a unit for the day you are moving
Pick a size and a move-in date in the next thirty days, and one unit of that size comes out of the pool and waits for you. Nothing is paid, nothing is signed, and the form will not offer you a day on which that size is full.